Fulton County Teachers' Unusual Bonds

One of the more interesting elements to emerge from the ongoing Atlanta Public School system scandal thus far has been the issue of bond. As has been widely reported, this week 35 public school educators and staff surrendered to the Fulton County jail after a grand jury returned indictments alleging the school officials engaged in racketeering , false statements, and illegally influencing witnesses. The case will undoubtedly play itself out in time, but the bonds set for the various educators have already perked the ears of Georgia’s legal community.

            In Georgia, the purpose of a bail bond is to ensure that a defendant will show up for upcoming court dates. The statutory factors to be determined when deciding bond are the defendant’s (1) risk of flight, (2) risk of posing danger to the community, (3) risk of committing a felony while out on bond, and (4) risk of intimidating witnesses. Further, bond is a judicial matter, meaning set by a judge. This is usually a magistrate judge but may also be a Superior Court judge in certain circumstances.

            The generally reported bonds set for the APS defendants are noteworthy in two respects. The first being their amount.  The Atlanta Journal Constitution reports that former APS superintendent Beverly Hall’s bond was set at $200,000 and several other teachers had bonds originally set at $400,000.

http://www.ajc.com/news/news/local/first-aps-cheating-scandal-defendant-surrenders/nW9Zx/

These bond amounts seem strangely high considering the bond factors listed above. None of the APS defendants have felonious criminal histories that have been publically reported. Additionally, all 35 defendants voluntarily turned themselves into the Fulton County jail. Given the high-profile nature of the case and the interest these educators have in defending against the charges, a risk of flight seems unlikely.

            However, the most curious thing about the bond amounts pertains to the grand jury’s involvement in the amounts being set. USA Today reports that Beverly Hall’s bond was initially set at $7.5 million and “the grand jury hearing the case suggested bond of $7.5 million for Hall” (emphasis added).

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/04/02/atlanta-school-cheating-scandal/2045139/

As mentioned above, setting bond in Georgia is a judicial function governed by statute. As such, only judges may grant bonds and it seems anomalous that a grand jury would take an active role in bond determination, even if only “suggesting” a bond amount.

Luckily for Hall and the others indicted, bond reductions were obtained for most of the educators and it seems as if they have all bonded out on the charges. It will be very interesting to see how the merits of this case develop and if the seemingly unique bond procedures bear any further legal challenges.

​